National Parents UnionResearch LibraryPollsPapersStates

Expanding Choice and Opportunity: Putting Families First in Education

Policy memo · 2025-07-25 · 2 pages

Original PDF

EXPANDING CHOICE AND OPPORTUNITY: Putting families first in education

Across the country, families are calling for common-sense reforms that remove barriers to high- quality education. One of the most overlooked and outdated barriers is rigid school attendance boundaries, which limit a family’s ability to choose the right school for their child. At the National Parents Union, we believe every family should have the freedom to choose a school that best meets the needs of their children.

THE PROBLEM: Outdated bureaucratic boundaries that limit opportunity

In too many school districts, government-mandated attendance zones tie children’s educational opportunities to where their family can afford to live. This system often locks hard-working American families out of higher-performing schools and better opportunities.

THE SOLUTION: Expanding public school choice to empower parents

Public school choice refers to public and accountable charter schools, magnet schools, open enrollment, and other programs that allow families to select from different public school options. The defining features of public school choice include:

Free: Public charter and magnet schools, like all public schools and unlike private schools subsidized by vouchers and ESA’s, are free and are barred from charging tuition. Public Oversight and Standards: Charter and magnet schools must adhere to state accountability measures, including standardized testing and curriculum guidelines. Fairness: Most public school choice programs must follow non-discriminatory enrollment policies and use lotteries when demand exceeds capacity. Stronger Evidence of Success: While not universally effective, research has shown that well- regulated charter schools, especially those serving low-income students, can lead to improved academic outcomes.

Denver Public Schools (DPS) is a testament to how successful open enrollment programs can be, and the success comes from their focus on providing families with access to schools they feel are the best fit for their children. Designed to be consistent and simple, DPS’ system maximizes the number of students getting their most-preferred school. Over 80% of students participated in the universal school choice process in Denver in 2023. The process has been highly effective in placing students in environments where they learn best, and test scores reflect that. Fourth grade reading scores on the NAEP have consistently gone up over time, and in 2024, the district saw a seven-point increase compared to other large cities.

www.nationalparentsunion.org Ariel Taylor Smith | ariel@npunion.org Senior Director of the NPU Center for Policy and Action

Polling shows broad, bipartisan support for open enrollment policies.

THE MISDIRECTION: Vouchers that waste taxpayer dollars Private school choice typically refers to policies such as voucher programs, education savings accounts, (ESAs) and tax-credit scholarships, which allow families to use public funds to pay for private school tuition. Most recently, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act approved the first national private school choice program, offering taxpayers a dollar-for-dollar credit of up to $1,700 for donations to scholarship-granting organizations.

While public school choice expands agency and opportunity for all families, most private school choice proposals divert resources away from public schools and come with minimal oversight or guarantees of quality. Concerns include:

Out-of-pocket costs for families: Available subsidies to families fall short of the full cost of private school tuition and expenses, often limiting participation to families that can afford thousands each year in supplementary costs. Inefficient use of taxpayer dollars: In most states with private school choice programs, at least two-thirds of participating families were already attending private schools before receiving public subsidies. Instead of expanding access, these programs simply shift costs to taxpayers, growing education budgets without meaningfully increasing opportunities. Lack of public accountability: Private schools receiving voucher students are usually not subject to the same transparency, standardized testing, or curriculum requirements as public schools. Waste, fraud, and abuse: There is little transparency or accountability regarding how families spend ESA funds, allowing for wasteful spending on golf stores, trampoline parks, $1,000 LEGO sets, and other luxury purchases.

Varied Academic Outcomes: Research, including NAEP data, has shown mixed to negative academic impacts for students using vouchers, particularly in states like Indiana, Louisiana, and Ohio, where students in voucher programs have demonstrated lower achievement levels compared to their public school peers.

We urge policymakers to empower every parent with the freedom to choose the best public school for their child, while reaffirming a commitment to effective and accountable public education.

www.nationalparentsunion.org Ariel Taylor Smith | ariel@npunion.org Senior Director of the NPU Center for Policy and Action