National Parents UnionResearch LibraryPollsPapersStates

The READ Act and Three-Cueing: How S. 4689 Would Encourage Investments in the Science of Reading

Policy memo · 2026-07-29 · 2 pages

Original PDF

The READ Act & Three-Cueing

How S. 4689 would encourage investments in the science of reading while supporting English Learners and preserving local autonomy ___________________________________________________________________________ The "three-cueing" approach teaches students to identify unfamiliar words by relying on meaning (pictures or context), sentence structure, and visual cues rather than decoding the letters and sounds in the word itself. While skilled readers naturally use context to understand what they read, decades of cognitive science show that context is not how beginning readers learn to recognize words. Successful reading depends on developing word recognition through explicit instruction in phonemic awareness, phonics, fluency, vocabulary, and comprehension. Research from cognitive psychology, neuroscience, and education consistently finds that encouraging children to guess words from pictures or context interferes with the development of efficient decoding. Skilled readers do not identify words by guessing from context; they recognize words rapidly because they have learned the relationships between letters and sounds and have stored those words in memory through repeated decoding.

Three-cueing particularly disadvantages struggling readers.

Students who have difficulty reading need more explicit instruction, not more guessing strategies. Research shows that struggling readers, including students with dyslexia and other reading difficulties, benefit from systematic phonics instruction because it teaches the alphabetic principle directly. Three-cueing instead encourages compensatory strategies that may mask reading difficulties while leaving decoding weaknesses unaddressed.

Students may appear to be reading successfully by memorizing predictable texts or relying on pictures, but these strategies break down quickly once illustrations disappear and vocabulary increases.

English learners deserve the same evidence-based instruction.

Every student deserves reading instruction grounded in evidence, and that includes English learners. The National Literacy Panel on Language-Minority Children and Youth reviewed nearly 2,000 studies and concluded that instruction in the core components of the science of reading benefits second-language learners much as it benefits native English speakers.

A child who arrives at school speaking Spanish (or any other language) is not starting from zero. Phonological awareness transfers across languages, meaning that literacy skills developed in one language support learning to read in another. But English contains many sound-symbol relationships that differ from other languages, particularly its vowel system. Those relationships must be taught explicitly. Students cannot be expected to infer them reliably through pictures or contextual guessing.

At the same time, phonics alone is not sufficient. English learners also need rich instruction in oral language, vocabulary, background knowledge, writing, and comprehension. The READ Act reflects this full body of evidence by defining the science of reading to include all of these essential components.

What the READ Act does.

The READ Act (S. 4689) ensures that federal Comprehensive Literacy State Development (CLSD) grant funds support evidence-based literacy instruction grounded in the science of reading. The bill:

● Requires literacy activities funded through CLSD grants to align with the science of reading. ● Prevents CLSD dollars from supporting instructional materials and professional development built around ineffective, discredited three-cueing approaches. ● Allows states and districts to continue to choose curriculum or instructional materials that meet the evidence standard. ● Continues to support evidence-based bilingual literacy instruction and requires parents to receive notifications about reading difficulties in their primary language.

What the READ Act does not do.

The READ Act does not ban three-cueing nationwide and does not create a federal curriculum mandate. Instead, it simply establishes an evidence standard for a voluntary competitive grant program. Specifically:

● Participation is voluntary. The requirements apply only to states that choose to apply for CLSD grants, and only to materials purchased with CLSD grants. ● No curriculum is prescribed. The bill requires alignment with the science of reading as a body of research, not any particular publisher, textbook, or instructional program. ● States retain local control. State and local educational agencies continue to select their own curricula, instructional materials, teacher preparation programs, and methods of implementation. ● There is clear precedent. The Reading First program under No Child Left Behind similarly required grant recipients to use scientifically based reading research without establishing a federal curriculum.

For these reasons, the READ Act is consistent with the Elementary and Secondary Education Act's longstanding prohibition on federal direction or control of curriculum. It does not dictate what schools must teach; it simply ensures that federal literacy dollars are spent on instructional approaches supported by the best available evidence.

The question is not whether schools may continue using three-cueing with their own funds. They may, if they are located in one of the 20 states that has not yet banned three-cuing in entirety. The question is whether federal taxpayer dollars should subsidize an instructional approach that decades of research have found is inconsistent with how children learn to read.

The READ Act answers that question by ensuring that federal literacy investments support evidence-based instruction that gives every child the opportunity to become a successful reader.